New disclosure context while the standard meaning of it verse is perhaps not, yet not, of the matter-of relationship so you can low-Muslims. Brand new classical interpretation states this particular verse got shown whenever a couple of polytheist people from Quraish wanted the siblings to be back, Oum Kelthoum and you can Bint Aqabah, once they got transformed into Islam and you can moved to Medina from inside the buy to join the latest Muslim neighborhood.

It general idea isn’t necessarily real while the “strength” or even the “weakness” of one’s religious belief isn’t regarding the gender however, rather towards the person’s identification and you may reputation

It’s well worth reminding that the Prophet closed during the time an agreement entitled Al-Hudaybya Treaty to the contrary group regarding Quraish to get rid of the fresh conflict getting a decade. Which arrangement stipulated, among others, one people Quraychit woman who would join the Prophet when you look at the Medina without having any consent away from the woman court tutor shall be sent back in order to Mecca.

Oum Kelthoum, who had been alone to transform so you’re able to Islam within her members of the family, and you will whom fled from a single really aggressive surroundings, begged the Prophet not to repatriate the woman in order to her group thus just like the to not ever end up being unwrapped once again to their unjust procedures.

The brand new verse above mentioned was then revealed to stop this new extradition of women just who converted to Islam and get away from this new vengeance away from their respective families. Therefore, new Prophet would not publish straight back the new exiled females towards opponents, since contract are managed for males.

The rationale of verse above mentioned signifies that it does perhaps not deal with in any way the wedding to non-Muslims, but is actually instead revealed to fulfill specific strategic conditions off securing women that converted to Islam from the usually of its members of the family and you may which voluntarily wanted this new Prophet’s shelter.

This new paradox we high light throughout these classical perceptions questions the brand new undeniable fact that according to this type of students, Muslim ladies are not allowed so you’re able to get married “disbelievers” also Christian and Jewish guys, if you are with the question of Muslim men, Christian and you can Jewish women are thought to be believers. How do we consider, in identical Religious or Jewish neighborhood, one guys are disbelievers while female of the same groups try believers?

Regarding the absence of people proof one justifies brand new ban out of the marriage of Muslim female on supporters regarding most other monotheistic religions, new contemporary scholars validate its perceptions by the “the pure tiredness” out of Muslim ladies who might have to go astray under the “bad” dictate of its Religious otherwise Jewish husbands. Nevertheless Muslim son could probably control their Religious or Jewish wife and you may manage his child’s and you will very own believe.

The fresh new Qur’anic verse, dealing with the wedding out of Muslim women or men to believers out-of almost every other religions, lay certain laws playing with a keen egalitarian vocabulary

In reality, the latest conflict isn’t persuading since if the fresh told you verse prohibits the marriage between bgclive Jak czyjeЕ› wiadomoЕ›ci an excellent Muslim woman and a great Religious or Jewish boy because it’s unanimously translated today, therefore instance relationships is even forbidden toward Muslim kid. Nonetheless, considering various Qur’anic verses in addition to Islamic ethics, Christians and Jews are considered unanimously since believers owned by religions revealed from the Allah long lasting existing variations in regards to this new dogma as well as the theological values.

As a result, the analysis of this verse suggests that brand new Qur’an prohibits the latest wedding of both Muslim visitors to polytheists.

However it is really worth bringing-up one students consent unanimously to your prohibition of the matrimony out of a beneficial Muslim woman to help you an effective Jewish or Christian, whenever you are zero part of the Qur’an provides for eg prohibition one warrants so it discrimination.